Ronni Bennett’s impending change of venue continues to inspire memories. In her most recent post, The Ten Percent Solution, she discusses an unexpected choice that’s been extended to her. She’s got a chance to stay in the city but one of the factors she has to weigh is that the apartment offered is a fourth story walk-up. Part of getting older is considering the possibility that what you can do today might not be so easy, or even possible, tomorrow.
The bulk of my years as a city child were spent living in one of those cavernous upper west side apartments. The leases on them went for something like twenty-five years at a time and could be passed on to family members. And the apartments were rent controlled. Before that, we lived in a much smaller place on West End Avenue and 72nd. It was a one bedroom and by the time I could form memories my maternal grandmother and I shared the bedroom while my parents slept on a sofa bed in the living room. My grandfather had died in my first year or so of my life and it’s never been clear to me how the family lost possession of the home in Connecticutt that he and my grandmother raised their family in, but lose it they did and my grandmother opted to move in with us.
Meanwhile, on West 87th, my paternal grandmother had died and my grandfather was in a nursing home. The ten room apartment that was that family’s home was now occupied by my aunt and uncle, who were not planning to have children, and my father’s uncle, a confirmed bachelor who would today probably be diagnosed with a mild case of Asberger’s Syndrome.
A decision was made to switch apartments. My aunt and uncle and their cat moved into our one bedroom and my grandmother, my parents and I moved north to the bigger place. My father’s uncle came with the big apartment and was part of our household from then on.
The 87th street building was ten stories and a penthouse. When built, each floor had just two huge apartments on it. It had changed ownership after WWII and the one abiding goal of the landlord was to rid the building of rent controlled units. When one of the original apartments was vacated it was broken up into several small ones and those, being entirely new apartments, were not subject to rent control restrictions. In addition to a desire to drive out the older tenants, the new landlord didn’t provide the services and maintenance that they’d been used to in the past. As far as my father was concerned, he was in a perennial state of war with the landlord or “that son of a bitch” as my father most usually called him.
When we arrived home from somewhere one evening, we found both elevators - the front one and the service elevator - out of order. We lived on the sixth floor and this wouldn’t have more than a big inconvenience, but my grandmother, who had serious rheumatoid arthritis, was with us and for her, walking up one flight of stairs would be problematic. Six was impossible. We were invited to encamp in a first floor apartment and that’s where we stayed until the landlord arrived. I think we were lying in wait. I was a kid. No one explained the finer points to me. All I remember was that when the landlord did arrive my father let loose a string of expletives I hadn’t ever heard from him before. The sight of him chasing the landlord up the street with my father yelling, “Come back here, you son of a bitch!”, both of them properly attired in business suits, overcoats and fedoras, was worth the wait to me.
Eventually, some way of carrying my grandmother upstairs was devised and of course, she had to stay there until the repairs were complete. This incident was one tiny item in an increasingly long list of things that motivated my parents to make the move to a house in suburbia. One reason that they chose the house that they eventually did was that it had a first floor bedroom for my grandmother. Floorplan is destiny? Maybe sometimes.